Rig building on a budget: Motherboards

image

Gaming discussionsGaming discussions

We take a look at the fundamentals of building a long lasting gaming rig on a budget

What does one do when faced with the need for a new gaming system? Of course, consoles provide a convenient all-in-one gaming solution, but there are those who want a bit of flexibility, customisability, and upgradeability on which to exercise their ‘pwning’ ability.  For this, the stalwart gaming PC still cannot be beaten.

Foundation

With future upgradeability in mind, one of the most important elements of the system is the motherboard. Though AMD and Intel both offer a variety of platform options, the same basic considerations apply.
The motherboard features are going to be the backbone of the system for the next few years, so it pays to spend a little extra in this area. Hopefully this guide will clear up some of the confusing issues surrounding motherboard choice.

Sockets

Intel has recently brought two new CPU sockets to market, the LGA 1366 and LGA 1156, supporting Nehalem based processors.

The LGA 1366 motherboards may be a little out of budget for value shoppers - currently around R2500 - but they are usually full featured, and provide an upgrade path to the future i9 branded processors. However, the LGA 1366 runs triple channel DDR3, so be prepared to spend more on RAM as well.

LGA 1156 motherboards are more budget friendly - starting at R1500 for boards with two ×16 mode PCI-E slots. LGA 1156 boards run dual channel DDR3, which will also save some money over the LGA 1366 triple channel variant.

LGA 775 socket motherboards can still be found, but they vary greatly in price depending on features (from R500 to over R2000). This socket supports the old Core 2 and Quad processors, which will still perform admirably for a gaming system over the next year or two, but there is no real upgrade path for these systems other than the GPU.

From AMD, socket AM2+ and the recent AM3 will both provide solid gaming systems with a good upgrade path. The sockets are cross compatible with the corresponding processors - AM3 processors will work on AM2+ sockets, and vice versa, but some features will be negated.

This provides an interesting choice for those currently in possession of an AM2+ CPU, in that they can splash out on an AM3 board, and upgrade the CPU at a later stage. Due to the small price difference, one should lean toward the AM3 socket motherboards, which come in at around R2000 for a high end gaming board.

PCI-Express 2.0 and Motherboard chipsets

Many motherboards will have ×16 sized slots with less than 16 PCI-E 2.0 data pathways connected to them. An ×16 slot with 8 data pathways is described as ×16 (×8 mode) for example.

These days, the north bridge chipset has had most of its functions moved over to the CPU, but it still plays the important role of managing the PCI-Express 2.0 link to the CPU. A common offering is two ×16 slots, one running in ×16 mode, and the other in ×8 mode, which provides a good upgrade path to multi GPUs.

Running two slots in ×8 mode will usually suffice bandwidth requirements for multi GPU setups, but some games that use extremely large textures (Crysis, Flight Simulator X, GTA IV) will see a performance hit. Only the top of the range AMD north bridge chipsets will offer two ×16 mode slots, and these boards may be out of range of the budget conscious. The Intel P55 chipset boards do offer more than one ×16 mode slot however, and these boards fall within the mid range budget.

MyGaming has previously discussed budget GPU choices to aid the conscientious spender.

Nvidia's Multi GPU SLI

SLI functionality can be found on boards sporting an nForce chipset, with the nForce 7xx chipsets being the latest, supporting the Intel LGA775 and AMD AM2+ CPU sockets. These are both aging sockets and may not be appealing for those building a new system with longevity in mind. Some Intel X58 and P55 chipsets support SLI, as long as the manufacturer has had them certified by Nvidia. Cards in SLI have to be of the same chipset model - i.e. two 8800 GTS 512 cards.

Nvidia also appears to be taking a step back from the gaming market for the time being, so it remains to be seen how many SLI compatible motherboards will emerge over the next few years. With Nvidia's top of the line GPUs overpriced and underperforming in comparison with the latest ATI offerings, it might be wise to lean in favour of an ATI graphics solution.

ATI's Multi GPU CrossfireX

ATI's CrossfireX is generally more friendly that SLI. Not only will most AMD motherboard chipsets support it, but so will most Intel chipsets, as ATI has opened up the architecture to Intel. Unlike SLI, the GPUs don't have be of the exact same model, but just of the same generation. An HD4850 and HD4870 will work together for example.

Final thoughts

The budget conscious gamer would do well to spend a little extra on the motherboard. On top of a decent board, one can use cheaper entry level parts, which can be upgraded as they age. CrossfireX is the most sensible multi GPU upgrade path at the moment. Both the Intel LGA 1156 and AM3 platforms will provide a solid foundation for a long lasting budget gaming rig.

Discuss Motherboards in the forums

AMD vs. Intel Hardware showdown at August Frag LAN

Natal’s biggest LAN hosts Intel vs. AMD competition ...

AMD's new 32nm Performance CPU - Bulldozer

AMD reveals two brand new CPU architectures ...

Comments (5 posted): Comments (5 posted):

Subscribe to comments feed
BSc. Elec Eng.
BSc. Elec Eng.
on 29/11/2009 21:44:51
AM2+ CPU's DO NOT work in AM3 motherboards.
Thumbs Up Thumbs Down
1
BSc. Elec Eng.
BSc. Elec Eng.
on 29/11/2009 22:04:40
I dont think the P55 supports Crossfire in x16/x16 config. Highest I've seen so far is x8/x8. (Unless if sum1's brought out some frankenstein Dual-Chipset Motherboard)

I believe this is an intentional design specification, which keeps Intel's X58 as the Hih-End/Enthusiast platform.
Thumbs Up Thumbs Down
1
AHEM!!!
AHEM!!!
on 17/12/2009 13:11:00
BSc.Elec.End. you should go ask your money back at the crappy university you when to!!

AM2+ cpu works on a AM3 m/b I HAVE A 9850 Black Edition on a ASUS M4A78-E AM3 m/b you dumb ass!!
Thumbs Up Thumbs Down
-3
BSc. Elec Eng.
BSc. Elec Eng.
on 19/12/2009 00:35:06
Ahem, i think I'll just call you Nancy from now on ,k?

Okay Nancy, you are wrong on three (maybe 4) levels.

1. You ASSumed I hav a degree, "dumb ass".

2.AM2+ CPU's CANNOT work on AM3 motherboards because they don't have DDR3 memory controllers.

3. Let's see you try to put an AM2+ CPU "on" a AM3 motherboard. AMD knew that idiots like you (yes Nancy, YOU!) exist so they made it PHYSICALLY impossible for an AM2+ CPU to fit in an AM3 motherboard. (There's an extra pin somewhere).

4. Nancy, your Asus M4A78-E m/b is an AM2+ motherboard. It just SUPPORTS AM3 CPU's.
AM2+ = DDR2 ; AM3 = DDR3.

Now next time you feel like commenting, make sure you use the name Nancy so we all know who you are.
Thumbs Up Thumbs Down
2
ZG
ZG
on 19/12/2009 13:51:47
Oh, why don't the two of you just compare pictures of your penises and get it over with?
Thumbs Up Thumbs Down
1
total: 5 | displaying: 1 - 5

Post your comment Post your comment